Challenges Facing the Critical Approach to Theological Systems

Author
Qodratullah Qorbani
Kharazmi University
10.22034/mi.2026.8537
Abstract
Theological systems encompass religious texts, believers' interpretations of these texts, and the religiosity of the faithful. Among the significant challenges to adopting a critical approach to theological systems are: the failure to distinguish between religious texts, religious knowledge, and religiosity; the dominance of exclusivist views of religion; extreme sanctimoniousness; the spread of religious populism; the prioritization of rituals and ceremonies over religious beliefs; personality-centric religiosity and neglect of the main message of religion; emotionalism and excitement-driven attitudes; the prevalence of imitative over investigative perspectives; and the professionalization of religion. Examining these challenges, identified inductively, helps us gradually transition from a dogmatic and non-critical view of theological systems to a critical and dialogue-oriented approach. Such a shift marks the beginning of accepting the reality of critique in the realm of religion and theological systems, leading to significant advancements.
Keywords
Theological Systems
Religion
Religious Knowledge
Religiosity
Exclusivism
Sanctimoniousness
Dialogue
The Holy Quran.
Ashari Abulhasan.1979. “Maqalat al-Islamiyyin wa Ikhtilaf al-Musallin.” H. Ritter, Ed. Wiesbaden. Franz Steiner Verlag.
Durant Will .1968. “The Lessons of History.” New York. Simon & Schuster Press.
Eller David .2007. “Introducing Anthropology of Religion.” UK. Routledge.
Esmaili Hadi & Ashna Hesamuddin .2013. “Cultural Religiosity.” Rahbord Farhang Journal. No. 23, Autumn 2013.
Fanaei Abulqasem .2016. “Religion on the Scale of Ethics.” Tehran. Serat Cultural Institute.
Farati Abdolvahhab .2010. “Clergy and Modernity.” Qom,. Research Institute of Islamic Culture and Thought.
Helali Salim Ibn Qeys .1996. “Secrets of the Family of Muhammad.” Translated by E. Ansari. Qom. Al-Hadi Publishing.
Hick John .1985. “Problems of Religious Pluralism.” UK. Palgrave Macmillan.
Javadi Amoli Abdollah .2008a. “The Status of Reason in the Structure of Religious Knowledge.” Qom. Esra Publications.
Javadi Amoli Abdollah .2008b. “Religious Studies.” Qom. Esra Publications.
Kulayni Muhammah Ibn Yaqoub .2009. “Al-Kafi.” Edited by A. A. Ghafari. Tehran. Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyyah Press.
McGrath Alister .1996. “Christian Theology: An Introduction.” Oxford University Press.
Motahhari Morteza .1993. “The Fundamental Problem in the Organization of Clergy.” Printed in: Ten Discourses, Tehran. Sadra Press.
Movehedian Attar Ali .2018. “Types of Religiosity; Characteristics, Damages, and Requirements.” Spiritual Studies Journal. No. 25, pp 7-35.
Moyaert Marianne .2011. “Fragile Identities: Towards a Theology of Interreligious Hospitality.” Amsterdam. New York. Rodopi.
Peterson Michael & Others .1991. “Reason and Religious Belief.” UK. Oxford University Press.
Qorbani Qodratullah. .2019. “The Role of Culture in Religiosity and the Network of Religious Knowledge.” Journal of Naqd va Nazar. No. 95. Autumn 2019.
Richards Glyn .2005. “Towards a Theology of Religions.” Translated by Reza Gandumi Nasrabadi & Ahmad Reza Meftah. Qom, University of Religions and Denominations Press.
Soroush Abdolkarim .1996b. “The Roof of Livelihood on the Pillar of Sharia.” Printed in: Tolerance and Governance. Tehran. Serat Publishing Institute.
Soroush Abdolkarim .1996a. “Freedom and Clergy.” Printed in: Tolerance and Governance. Tehran. Serat Publishing Institute.
Stenmark Mikael .2006. “Exclusivism, Tolerance, and Interreligious Dialogue.” Journal of Interreligious Dialogue, No. 16.
Swidler Leonard .2014. “Dialogue for Interreligious Understanding.” New York. Palgrave Macmillan.
Tabatabaei Mohammad Hossein .2012. “Teachings of Islam.” Qom. Boustan Ketab Press.
Shahrestani Habbatollah .1930. “Our Scholars and Publicizing the Truth.” Journal of Al-'Ilm, o. 2, Najaf.